Pie Time! The Top 10 Delicious Pies Around the USA
America's Preferred Pie, as Per Instacart's Survey Results
Looking to celebrate Pi(e) Day with a scrumptious dessert? Instacart, America's go-to grocery delivery and pick-up platform, has compiled data on the most popular pies consumed throughout 2024. Read on to discover the nation's sweet tooth preferences!
The Almighty Apple Pie
Vying for the crown of America's favorite pie, according to Instacart, is none other than the classic apple pie. With a whopping 29% of all pie sales, this warm, delightful dessert takes the top spot.
Pumpkin Pie Holds a Close Second
Coming in a close second, pumpkin pie boasts an impressive 23% of pie sales in the United States. Especially popular during the Thanksgiving season, its demand skyrockets on the West Coast and in Florida year-round.
A Hearty Bite of Pecan Pie
Claiming the third spot, pecan pie accounts for 9% of pie sales nationwide. Particularly cherished in the South, this luscious pie has a strong fanbase.
The Fourth and Fifth Favorites: Cherry and Lemon Meringue Pies
With 8% of pie sales each, cherry pie and lemon meringue pie share the fourth and fifth positions. Imbued with a cascade of tangy, fruity flavors, these delectable desserts are perfect for diner-style indulgence or a backyard barbecue.
The Complete Top Ten List
Here's the complete list of the country's favorite pies:
- Apple Pie, 29%
- Pumpkin Pie, 23%
- Pecan Pie, 9%
- Cherry Pie, 8%
- Lemon Meringue Pie, 6%
- Blueberry Pie, 5%
- Chocolate Pie, 4%
- Key Lime Pie, 4%
- Other Pies (including Marionberry and Sweet Potato Pie), 3%
- Peach Pie, 3%
Homemade Bakers Take Center Stage
For those who prefer whipping up their own pies at home, Instacart reported a significant trend in Vermont, with residents purchasing pie-baking essentials an astounding 83% more frequently than the national average.
Get Your Pie Fix Today!
Whether you're craving the sweet taste of pie or the urge to experiment in your own kitchen, you can rely on Instacart to fulfill your desires. Delight in unique raisin cream or Texas trash pie recipes crafted at home or have your favorite pie delivered right to your doorstep!
The Sensational Crust for Double-Crust Pie
Relevant Insights (15% of the total content):
- Data from 2024 was collected and analyzed by Instacart to determine the top 10 most popular pies in the United States
- Pies such as Marionberry and Sweet Potato Pie have a dedicated following but are not individually ranked in the top 10 due to being part of the broader "other" category
- States on the West Coast and Florida have a year-round demand for pumpkin pie, as opposed to its typical popularity during the fall season
- Instacart, America's preferred grocery delivery platform, found that apple pie holds the highest sales at 29%, making it the most popular pie consumed in 2024.
- Pumpkin pie comes in a close second with an impressive 23% of pie sales, particularly popular in Florida and on the West Coast year-round.
- Pecan pie accounts for 9% of pie sales, especially cherished in the southern states.
- Cherry and lemon meringue pies, each with 8% of pie sales, offer a cascade of tangy, fruity flavors perfect for various occasions.
- The complete list of the country's favorite pies includes apple pie, pumpkin pie, pecan pie, cherry pie, lemon meringue pie, blueberry pie, chocolate pie, key lime pie, other pies (such as Marionberry and Sweet Potato Pie), and peach pie, with each category accounting for specific percentages of pie sales.
- Vermont residents are known for their love of homemade pies, purchasing pie-baking essentials 83% more frequently than the national average.
