Roofing Material Comparison: The Advantages and Disadvantages of Metal versus Cedar Shingles
Are you considering a new roof for your home? Two popular options to consider are standing seam metal roofs and cedar shake roofs. Both offer unique benefits and drawbacks, and the choice between them depends on various factors.
Standing Seam Metal Roofs
Standing seam metal roofs consist of vertical metal panels that run from the ridge of the roof to the eaves. These roofs offer significant benefits, including:
- Exceptional durability, lasting 40 to 70+ years with proper maintenance.
- Superior resistance to harsh weather such as high winds (up to 140 mph), hail, heavy rain, fire, mildew, insects, and rot.
- Excellent moisture protection thanks to raised seams and concealed fasteners that prevent leaks even during severe storms.
- Energy efficiency because their metal surfaces reflect solar radiant heat, potentially lowering cooling costs by up to 25%.
- Minimal maintenance compared to traditional roofing.
- A sleek, modern aesthetic that can enhance curb appeal.
- Environmentally friendly, often made from recycled metals and fully recyclable at end of life, and their surface is well-suited for solar panel installation.
- Well-adapted to low slope roofs and can provide effective drainage without pooling water.
However, the primary drawback is a higher initial cost than traditional options, though this can be offset by long-term savings and durability.
Cedar Shake Roofs
Cedar shake roofs are traditional roofing materials made from split logs of cedar trees. They are appreciated for their natural, rustic appearance and insulation properties. However, in comparison to standing seam metal roofs, cedar shakes typically require more maintenance, are more vulnerable to fire, rot, mildew, and insect damage, and usually have a shorter lifespan (generally around 20-30 years). They may also be less resistant to severe weather conditions such as high winds and hail.
| Feature | Standing Seam Metal Roofs | Cedar Shake Roofs | |--------------------------|---------------------------------------------------------|----------------------------------------------------| | Lifespan | 40-70+ years | 20-30 years | | Weather Resistance | High (wind up to 140 mph, hail, fire, moisture) | Moderate to low (susceptible to rot, insects) | | Maintenance | Low (occasional inspection and cleaning) | High (regular sealing, repairs) | | Energy Efficiency | High (reflects solar heat, reduces cooling costs) | Moderate (natural insulation but not reflective) | | Appearance | Sleek, modern, clean lines | Natural, rustic, warm aesthetic | | Environmental Impact | Often recycled and fully recyclable | Natural material but less recyclable if treated | | Installation Cost | Higher initial cost but long-term savings | Generally lower initial cost but higher upkeep | | Suitability for Low Slopes | Excellent, prevents pooling water | Less suitable, requires steeper slopes | | Fire Resistance | High (many Class A rated) | Low to moderate, unless specially treated |
Making the Right Choice
The choice between standing seam metal roofs and cedar shake roofs depends on various factors, such as budget, desired look, climate, and maintenance willingness. Standing seam metal roofs provide superior durability, weatherproofing, and energy efficiency with low maintenance and a modern look, making them an excellent long-term investment, especially in harsh climates. Cedar shake roofs offer a traditional, natural aesthetic but come with more maintenance requirements and less resistance to environmental stresses.
Contact Heather and Little to schedule a consultation for a new roof with either cedar shingles or metal shingles. Their expertise can help with roofing vision realization for both standing seam metal roofs and cedar shake roofs.
- For homeowners seeking a durable, low-maintenance, and energy-efficient roof with a modern aesthetic, standing seam metal shingles are an excellent choice, making them suitable for home-improvement and home-and-garden enthusiasts in various lifestyles.
- In contrast, cedar shingles can lend a traditional, rustic charm to any home, but their higher maintenance requirements and lower resistance to environmental factors may not align with the preferences of individuals aiming for a low-maintenance lifestyle.
